This pie isn’t available all the time but it is still worth a mention and worth a try if you can get hold of it. This pub modestly claims to be one of the best in the Peak District, but from what I’ve seen, it’s not far off the truth. I’m quite happy to research this further, mind you.
Anyway, if the pies don’t grab you, the ales certainly will as this place is basically a Thornbridge tap, situated as it is, just down the road from the famous Bakewell brewery, so perhaps this is more of a good beer review than a good pie review.
I worked my way down the pumps from the Helles style lager, Lukas; the Brother Rabbit pale ale and of course a pint or two of Jaipur, their 5.9% cask IPA.
But the pies, the sweet, sweet pies. They had both a gamekeeper’s pie (£15) and a Homity pie (£14) on when I visited. I plumped for the former, while my good lady had the latter.
Not got great photos of either, it kind of explains why I try and avoid having mash and gravy with my pies. 1. It doesn’t make for a clear view or the pie and 2. It can obfuscate the flavour within the pie.
Yes, I did use the word “obfuscate” in a pie review and yes, you’re right, that DOES appear to be a mash, rather than crust topping. Nevertheless, the pie was splendid and the chips and pickled cabbage weren’t bad either.
The Gamekeeper’s pie contained rabbit, venison and pheasant, along with sweet potato, carrot and onion inside and the Homity pie (which the missus’ loved) was mainly sweet potato, carrot, cheese and other veg, served with a radish salad.
Sadly, no inclusion in the GPG though as the menu is on rotation and pies aren’t always on it ☹
Nevertheless, a fully loaded, log fire with my in-laws giant dog, Wilf, snuggled up to it, really helpful and friendly staff and loads of real ales after a day of walking the Monsal Trail all made for a lovely day and I can recommend this place highly if you’re in the area.
The finer details
Date: 29th December 2021
Price: The price was £15 for the Gamekeeper’s Pie
Address: Main St, Little Longstone, Bakewell DE45 1NN
Click here to add a pie review of your own: https://goodpieguide.co.uk/add-pie/
You can buy a copy of Life of Pies here for just £4.99 plus P&P