8 September 2012
Linked product
7.6/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Ellison's Steak Pie
Shop:
Ellison's of Redcar
Ellisons has a big blue canopy next to the Standard pub and as I saunter in, a woman with close cropped hair picks up on me immediately. She enthusiastically goes through the full...
Read review →
8 September 2012
Linked product
7.3/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Blackwell's Pork Pie
Shop:
Blackwell's of Norton
Blackwell’s produce a solid Smoggie growler which doesn't look that deep from the top but from the cross section there seems adequate volume to it. The pork is chewy in texture off...
Read review →
7 September 2012
Linked product
7.5/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Botham's Yorkshire Pasty
Shop:
Botham's of Whitby
Bothams of Whitby are famed for their pork pies; of which they have none. When I ask the lady what she has left, she murmurs off a list of items which don't exactly arrest my atten...
Read review →
7 September 2012
Linked product
7.8/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Higgidy Chicken, Ham and Leek Pie
Shop:
Higgidy Pies
I’m not sure of the wisdom of including the word POT in the pie description, as it very often has negative connotations in the pie world. A pie should not be made in a pot, it shou...
Read review →
1 September 2012
Linked product
8.4/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Gent's Meat and Potato Pie
Shop:
Gents Pie Shop
Gents doesn't look much of a place, you wouldn't even know it was there unless you were looking for it. There's no signs or advertisements, just a few cakes and loaves stacked in r...
Read review →
1 September 2012
Linked product
8.1/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Gent's Hot Pot
Shop:
Gents Pie Shop
Look, this is primarily a pie site but there is still room for at least one example of an individually portioned Lancashire hot pot and there is no place better than Gents to get i...
Read review →
25 August 2012
Linked product
5.9/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Plested Steak and Kidney Pie
Shop:
Plested Pies
Plesteds is Southampton's Premier Pie Shop: traditional savoury and fruit pies. For a shop which seems so big on pies, they don't seem to have an awful lot of variety. They've got...
Read review →
17 August 2012
Linked product
8.7/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Green's Meat and Potato Pie
Shop:
Green's Pie Shop
Greens sell nothing else other than pies, cakes and a few bottles of pop and it really is like a step back in time as working class Barrovians wait for their lunch. There's a polit...
Read review →
11 August 2012
Linked product
8.5/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Bowen Meat and Potato Pie
Shop:
Bowen Pies
Bowen Pies are not in Wigan but they may as well be given the volume of Wigan Pies they send to shops and pubs in the area. They do a full range but their meat and potato is one of...
Read review →
11 August 2012
Linked product
7.8/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Hall's Potato and Meat Pie
Shop:
Halls Bakers
The Hall’s potato and meat is another great pie where the meat juices fusion perfectly with the potato, and there's possibly a bit of swede in there for good measure. Perhaps room...
Read review →
10 August 2012
Linked product
7.7/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Sean's Bakery Steak and Potato Pie
Shop:
Sean's Steak and Potato Pie
I’m served by a cheery Irish chap whom I don’t know if he’s Sean himself but like everything else he's also totally green or at least wearing a big green apron to match the big Iri...
Read review →
10 August 2012
Linked product
7.1/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Helen's Steak and Potato Pie
Shop:
Helen's Bakery
Helen’s bakery in Sheffield produces a steak and potato pie where the crust disintegrates when removed from the tray. It expires in my fingers into a dozen pieces. Just as well it...
Read review →
10 August 2012
Linked product
7.6/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Staniforth's Steak and Potato Pie
Shop:
Staniforth's Bakery
During my visit to Sheffield, Staniforths (of Rotherham incidentally) are the only purveyor to supply me with a hot pie all day. It again has a high meat ratio, sweet gravy and a d...
Read review →
9 August 2012
Linked product
7.6/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Bakewell Tart Shop Lamb & Leek Pie
Shop:
Bakewell Tart Shop
Although it’s primary product is, of course, the Bakewell Tart, The Bakewell Tart Coffee house also serve a raft of pasties and a range of pies including a Huntsman’s pie (lamb, tu...
Read review →
9 August 2012
Linked product
7.6/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Bere's Steak and Potato Pie
Shop:
Beres Pork Shop
Bere’s are well known pork purveyors in Sheffieold but they also do pies. Their steak and potato has a rugged crust lip with a dark, lardy glaze and there is an almost wholly meat...
Read review →
9 August 2012
Linked product
8.0/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Lily's Steak and Potato Pie
Shop:
Lily's Bakery
Lily’s in Sheffield is a big place, serving bit pies. I order a steak and potato which arrives in a splendidly encased shortcrust. It is served cold but in a delightful wrapper: “G...
Read review →
6 August 2012
Linked product
7.7/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Bellfield's Meat and Potato Pie
Shop:
Bellfields
I’m in Bollington on the edge of the Peak District, home to what is known colloquially as a “Bellfields Bollington Belter”. I order a meat and potato which has soft, dark pastry an...
Read review →
3 August 2012
Linked product
7.7/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Greenhalgh's Chicken Tikka Pie
Shop:
Greenhalgh's Bakery
Greenhalghs are prevalent in Wigan despite being from across the border in Bolton. They possess a wide range of pies and this time I opt for the season special that is the chicken...
Read review →
3 August 2012
Linked product
8.3/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Galloway's Meat and Potato Pie
Shop:
Galloways Bakers
Galloways is truly a Wigan institution. It definitely wasn’t the first, but it probably now lays claim to being the home of the meat and potato pie. The pastry is beautifully soft...
Read review →
27 July 2012
Linked product
7.3/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Stoke Bakery Chicken Balti Slice
Shop:
Stoke Bakery
I am trying to get hold of a chicken Balti pie, seeing as they are made around here by Shire Foods in Leamington, and I land upon the Stoke Bakery. There are sausage Rolls plus del...
Read review →
27 July 2012
Linked product
7.0/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
J Taylor & Son Chicken Pie
Shop:
J Taylor & Son
I find John Taylor’s butchers perched on the corner of a long dipping street of terraced houses which winds all the way down into the city and I am greeted by a gentleman who calls...
Read review →
27 July 2012
Linked product
7.3/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Walter Smith Steak Pie
Shop:
Walter Smith Butchers
Walter’s gaff has meat and sausages down one side, pies down the other. I spot the pork pies too late: they’re nearly three quid with a dark crust but I want something to eat now w...
Read review →
27 July 2012
Linked product
8.0/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Urban Pie Steak & Stilton Pie
Shop:
Urban Pie
Urban Pie looks a great place for lounging outside watching the well heeled Brummies sauntering in and out of the Hugo Boss shop. They do a fine range of flavours including Aberdee...
Read review →
27 July 2012
Linked product
7.4/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Chilly Billy's Pork Pie
Shop:
Chilly Billy's
Chilly Billys stall. Market stall prices, market stall value: you can have two chicken and mushroom or mince and onion for a quid, or two Cornish pasties for the same price or just...
Read review →