19 June 2012
Linked product
6.9/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Kelly's Minced Beef Pie
Shop:
G Kelly
The filling tastes cheap but then that’s the whole idea so nothing wrong with the ample layer of mince inside. The pastry however is char grilled in parts and the top crust gives w...
Read review →
17 June 2012
Linked product
7.6/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Bell's Mini Steak and Gravy Pie
Shop:
Bells Foods
According to THE INTERNET, Bells are Scotland’s number one pastry brand who do a wide range of pies and at three pies for a quid I figure they might be worth a wee punt in the dire...
Read review →
16 June 2012
Linked product
7.5/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
T&M Mayoh Meat and Potato Pie
Shop:
T&M Mayoh
It's jam packed with some huge slabs of spud in there smothering juicy knots of mince meat. The crust is thick but gentle with a soft not soggy bottom as potato based runny gravy c...
Read review →
16 June 2012
Linked product
8.1/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Burnden Park Pie Shop Meat and Potato Pie
Shop:
Burnden Park Pie Shop
Mine host is a gent, scholar and pie maker extraordinaire in spite of this place's supposed "Sweeney Todd" reputation. The pastry is a bit thick and stubbly for my liking but the p...
Read review →
11 June 2012
Linked product
7.4/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Jessie Smith's Wychwood Pork Pie
Shop:
Jessie Smith’s Butchers
Low on jelly but lots of reasonably cured pork meat encased in a tough water based pastry that was very dark even before I warm it up. It's a hefty pie and a growler with a proper...
Read review →
11 June 2012
Linked product
7.8/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
M Hart & Son Venison & Burgundy Pie
Shop:
M Hart & Son
I’m served by a cheerful chap with a large moustache who comments about the awful weather. The pastry is superb: split into several layers, crispy on the outside gradually getting...
Read review →
9 June 2012
Linked product
7.4/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Purbeck Smokey Pork Pie
Shop:
Purbeck Smokeys
Essentially I've no idea what this was and haven't been able to find anything about it subsequent to publication. However, it twirled around and folded in like a gift wrapped prese...
Read review →
9 June 2012
Linked product
7.7/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Bridport Pork and Blue Vinney Pie
Shop:
Bridport Gourmet Pies
A decorative oval shaped pie with a map of Dorset in the top crust. The cheesy bit a touch subtler than I'd expected and takes a while to register but it gets there in the end and...
Read review →
8 June 2012
Linked product
7.2/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Bennett's Cornish Pasty
Shop:
Bennett’s Bakery
It says on the shelves they have steak pies but I can’t see any and it’s barely ten to eleven in the morning so I’m left with a choice of pasties. She's dead nice with me so I ask...
Read review →
8 June 2012
Linked product
7.3/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Idah's Patisserie Meat and Potato Pie
Shop:
Idah’s Patisserie
Speedy service plus I get a fork AND a serviette for just £1.55. The sort of pie best eaten upside down with a dense top crust and a floppy base and this tactic just about keeps th...
Read review →
7 June 2012
Linked product
7.2/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Dutch Oven Meat and Potato Pie
Shop:
Dutch Oven
I am attended to straight away by two pleasant Pam Ayres type ladies on a grim day giving it a ‘what can I get you my luv?' It has a firm and sturdy crust but there is considerabl...
Read review →
7 June 2012
Linked product
7.4/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Sabin's Deli Pork Pie
Shop:
Sabin’s Deli
The crust is hand raised and beautifully formed with a lovely softness to it whilst the filling is succulent and intense, a real fillip on a particularly shitty day. This review is...
Read review →
5 June 2012
Linked product
7.0/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Eagle's Pork Pie
Shop:
Eagle’s Deli
Delicately cased with a lattice top crust and plenty of jelly in the lining of the pie, the sausage meat was slightly coarse but very soft, perhaps a little bit dry when eaten at r...
Read review →
5 June 2012
Linked product
8.0/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
The Crown & Tuns Steak and Old Hookey Ale Pie
Shop:
The Crown and Tuns
I get a steak and Old Hookey Ale pie with chips, veg and a jug of gravy for £11.95. Extra mark to the girl behind the bar for being dead sweet with my daughter whilst she rampaged...
Read review →
2 June 2012
Linked product
7.5/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Hurst's Pork Pie
Shop:
Hurst’s Bakery
I am presented with a thick, juicy pork pie which is hand raised with an almost regal looking crown on top. I don't detect a lot of jelly in there but it's meaty and succulent enou...
Read review →
2 June 2012
Linked product
6.9/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Phil Manion's Steak Pie
Shop:
Phil Manion
It’s small and sparsely populated with meat inside, however it is remarkably cheap with a soft oblong shaped crust
Read review →
31 May 2012
Linked product
7.9/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Finigan's Meat and Potato Pie
Shop:
Finigan’s Bakery
As I arrive at Finigans, the poor lass is run off her feet. The pie has a proper sticky glaze to bite into whereupon there is a mash of potato with small chunks of beef to chomp in...
Read review →
27 May 2012
Linked product
7.6/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Clayton Park Potato and Meat Pie
Shop:
Clayton Park
A layered potato filling, well seasoned and peppery, heavily glazed, sticky top crust with a well defined crimp to it. “Creating true British masterpieces” it says on the wrapper....
Read review →
22 May 2012
Linked product
7.7/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Chatwin's Meat and Potato Pie
Shop:
Chatwin’s Bakery
I eventually find Chatwins next to the Northwich Victoria club shop only for them to tell me they have no pies left but come back in five minutes. The second time I walk into Chat...
Read review →
22 May 2012
Linked product
7.8/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Webb's Meat and Potato Pie
Shop:
C Webb & Sons
A splendid butchers with sawdust in the floor, it is a sturdy, robust pie, heavy enough to knock a featherweight boxer out. Big lumps of glistening potato combined with smaller chu...
Read review →
21 May 2012
Linked product
6.9/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Fray Bentos Steak and Boozy Ale Pie
Shop:
Fray Bentos
Upon dismantling this beast, I feel slightly underwhelmed at the lack of meat content and quickly up-end the lid onto a plate to find out where it is hiding, burning my hands on th...
Read review →
19 May 2012
Linked product
8.0/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Haffner's Meat and Potato Pie
Shop:
Haffner’s Butchers
A big hitter from Burnley that hits the mark in more ways than one. It has a crispy, dark outer top crust and firm base but softer interior. There is a prize winning waft hits me u...
Read review →
19 May 2012
Linked product
6.8/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Boundary Mill Pork and Apple Pie
Shop:
Boundary Mill
Eaten cold, this is a dinky looking pie who's filling sadly fails to make it all the way to the top, although I do like the introduction of apple into the mix. Despite being a tall...
Read review →
19 May 2012
Linked product
7.3/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Oddie's Potato Pie
Shop:
Oddie’s Bakery
A rich, herby potatoey filling, exactly as it says on the tin (foil) with the occasional piece of mince in there. Nevertheless, a solid, traditional bakers. Incidentally, the owner...
Read review →