23 February 2022
Linked product
7.1/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Bakewell Tart Shop Steak and Ale Pie
Shop:
Bakewell Tart Shop
It is quite a deep and heavy pie, which is always a pleasing sight, marked with a triangle on top to denote the flavour. As it cooks in the oven, I can confirm a slight buttery waf...
Read review →
24 August 2020
Linked product
8.1/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Pieminister Shamrock Pie
Shop:
Pieminister
As I’m sure everyone knows, Pieminster are two blokes from Bristol who love pies and have built up a cult following with restaurant stockists and stores, publishing books with reci...
Read review →
19 August 2020
Linked product
7.0/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Cranston's Meat and Potato Pie
Shop:
Cranstons
Sunday morning. In Keswick. Hung over and need petrol. Even the natural beauty of the Borrowdale pass and the invigorating calm of Derwent Water isn't clearing my head. There's a p...
Read review →
27 February 2019
Linked product
7.3/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Pooles Pies Chunky Steak Pie
Shop:
Pooles Pies
Purchased from Asda, Pooles Pies are not what they were when I was growing up. At a mere 84 pence though it’s hard to complain. The pastry is crumbly and heartburn inducing but the...
Read review →
27 February 2019
Linked product
6.7/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Reids Meat and Potato Pie
Shop:
Reids
The staff are attentive and courteous and hand me an oblong shaped pie with a soft, supple crust. Unfortunately, despite it’s £1.10 price tag, it is terribly small and half of it s...
Read review →
20 December 2013
Linked product
7.3/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
The Crusty Pie Company Chunky Steak and Yorkshire Ale Pie
Shop:
The Crusty Pie Company
Despite some early concerns about pricing and freshness the Crusty Pie Company Steak and ale pie is exceptionally filling and leaves my appetite feeling decidedly battle weary, the...
Read review →
7 December 2013
Linked product
7.9/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Paul's Christmas Pie
Shop:
Paul's Pies
The Christmas pie is an open topped affair but the layering is truly spectacular on the eye: cranberry topping, followed by stuffing, which dominates proceedings and tastes as rich...
Read review →
30 November 2013
Linked product
8.0/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Burbush's Pork and Caramelised Gooseberry Pie
Shop:
Burbush's Pies
It is a highly rigid effort, albeit with no top crust, which is kind of expected with a fruit topped pie. The prospect of the semi-pureed fruity topping sinking into the meat compe...
Read review →
30 November 2013
Linked product
8.1/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Great North Pie Co Boxing Day Turkey Pie
Shop:
Great North Pie Co
The crust is drizzled with sesame seeds and has a circular Scotch pie form to it with acute angles. I nuzzle up to it before putting in the oven and it has a reassuringly authentic...
Read review →
9 November 2013
Linked product
8.1/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Paul's Picnic Pie
Shop:
Paul's Pies
The P for picnic has depressed into the lid a touch but the now familiar magnificent crown shape of the top crust marks this out as a prestige pie. Of course the beauty of this is...
Read review →
9 November 2013
Linked product
8.4/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Paul's Steak & Guinness Pie
Shop:
Paul's Pies
The combination of shortcrust and suet pastry is beyond perfect. The top crust resembles a crown and this is certainly a pie fit for a king. The craftsmanship exhibited in creating...
Read review →
9 November 2013
Linked product
7.6/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
NZ Gourmet steak and cheese pie
Shop:
NZ Gourmet pies
Ever so slightly flaky but it's a crust which really grows on me and hangs together well. It smells sumptuously cheesy in the oven as you’d expect and contains whopping chunks of s...
Read review →
9 November 2013
Linked product
8.1/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
NZ Gourmet Mike's Chilli Beef Pie
Shop:
NZ Gourmet pies
It's a bit flaky but somehow this perfectly complements the fiery contents inside, the top crust comes perilously close to detaching itself mind you. It is packed with chilli beef...
Read review →
9 November 2013
Linked product
8.1/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Legges' The Publican Pie
Shop:
Legges of Bromyard
This pie looks moodily dark even before it goes into the oven and I'm getting heartburn just looking at it, yet the crust is surprisingly light and holds its shape remarkably well....
Read review →
2 November 2013
Linked product
7.2/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Davidson's Steak Pie
Shop:
Davidson's
There’s no doubting the authenticity or quantity of the succulent steak meat but for me it’s lacking a bit of gravy as it’s a touch on the dry side.
Read review →
2 November 2013
Linked product
7.6/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Davidson's Kiwi Pie
Shop:
Davidson's
The pie presents in the now familiar circular tin form, with a generous blob of dried cheese of top as a prelude to what lurks inside. It is not the deepest but there are plenty of...
Read review →
2 November 2013
Linked product
8.0/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Davidson's Minced Beef Bridie
Shop:
Davidson's
It's a little flaky yet it pulls off, as the base is splendidly dark and tasty, in that sweet semi-burnt kind of way. The pastry seduces me whilst it's heating in the oven. It look...
Read review →
7 October 2013
Linked product
7.7/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Mhor Bakery Steak & Black Pudding Pie
Shop:
Mhor Bakery
The soft texture of the black pudding compliments the tougher steak, perfectly wrapped up in a thick juicy gravy, leaving you in no doubt who’s the boss here. A very Mhor’ish pie i...
Read review →
7 October 2013
Linked product
7.9/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Bennett's Steak & Pepper Pie
Shop:
Bennett's Deli
An ever so slightly soft, lardy pastry with a bit of give on the sides moulded in the traditional Scottish tin shape. It is chockful of stringy braised steak, which thankfully isn’...
Read review →
7 October 2013
Linked product
7.6/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Mhor Bakery Minced Steak Bridie
Shop:
Mhor Bakery
The filling doesn’t extend all the way across, but what there is possesses a higher meat content than your average English pasty, with fewer random root vegetables. The mincemeat i...
Read review →
7 October 2013
Linked product
7.8/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Main Street Bakery Scotch Pie
Shop:
Main Street Bakery
It’s already a bit dark before it goes in the oven and the egg glaze permeates through whilst it’s warming. The crunch of the crust marries perfectly with the delicate fluffy light...
Read review →
6 October 2013
Linked product
8.0/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Browning's Killie Pie
Shop:
Browning's The Bakers
The whole package is very light, even when in the box but the crust is remarkably thorough, given its weight and follows the traditional round Scottish shape. It is scorching hot a...
Read review →
6 October 2013
Linked product
7.9/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Pollok Williamson Scotch Pie
Shop:
Pollok Williamson Butchers
It’s laced with more salt than a Siberian outpost, but the meat simply melts in my mouth with a hit so sharp, it’s like receiving a hefty kick to the plums. The filling is generous...
Read review →
6 October 2013
Linked product
7.5/10
Good Pie Guide rating
Product:
Browning's Steak and Haggis Pie
Shop:
Browning's The Bakers
As with the Killie pie, the second half ramps it up a bit but admittedly this isn’t perfect to old fussykecks tastes being a wee Sassenach and I’d probably be happier with just ste...
Read review →